Rare Common Sense

Miss California Conflict…*No Offense*

Posted by: commonsensegirl on: April 21, 2009

The Miss USA pageant should be grateful for Miss California’s complete lack of acceptance, tolerance and/or political-correct-ness.  It has given the show more attention than it has garnered in years.  Seriously, when was the last time you made note of any beauty pageant, except on an lazy evening where you’re channel surfing and stumble upon it. Very few people plan to watch the pageants, and those who do mostly tune in for the opportunity to mock the fake smiles, orange tans and canned responses to bland questions. 

As you’ve no doubt read, this year was different.

When asked to share her thoughts on gay marriage, and whether or not states should follow Vermont in legalizing it, Miss California had this to say:

“I think it’s great Americans are able to choose one or the other.  We live in a land that you can choose same-sex marriage or opposite marriage. And you know what in my country, in my family I think that I believe that a marriage should be between a man and a woman. No offense to anybody there, but that’s how I was raised and that’s how I think it should be, between a man and a woman.”

Granted, this question was asked by Perez Hilton, well-known blogger, as well as a gay man and advocate, so there is some added pressure.  However, it is clear Miss California fell far short of an answer that a beauty pageant participant would have been coached to answer.  And I guess we should respect her for giving her honest answer, and foregoing the scripted, rehearsed answer.

Unfortunately, her answer also showed how little progress has been made regarding GLBT rights.  While our country encourages personal beliefs, it is important to note that they are exactly that – personal.  The basis of our country’s foundation was that the tired, poor, hungry and sick could come here and make a life for themselves without the threat of persecution.  So while Miss California may personally believe, based on her religion, that gay marriage is wrong, it also calls into question her ability to represent our nation as Miss USA.  After all, isn’t this title meant to demonstrate that the woman wearing the crown is the best possible representative for our nation as a whole?

Miss California seems to think that her answer was in defense of her faith, and represents her personal values.  But refusing the right of marriage to GLBT community members makes them second-class citizens.  Part of Christianity is love, acceptance and kindness.  As a Christian myself, I can’t imagine Jesus Christ walking the Earth today and preaching the love of God and eternal life to all……except gays.

While Miss California may think she is on some kind of crusade by defending her answer, I am disappointed to see a woman with a tremendous opportunity to serve as an advocate for acceptance using the stage to further the outdated beliefs.

And on a side-note, prefacing your answer with “no offense” does not mean you are exempt for the consequences of your statements.

*This post will no doubt be followed with a lot of comments calling me a dike or fag-lover.  While I’m not gay personally, I do consider myself an advocate for their rights.  The mistreatment of any citizen of our great country should outrage us all.

**I love Perez Hilton, and am proud that he works so hard to protect the rights of others.

2 Responses to "Miss California Conflict…*No Offense*"

To start off, let me address your comment on “no offense.” I don’t know what Miss CA meant by saying that, but I can tell you that when I use that phrase, I truly do mean “this is not meant to attack you (my audience) personally.” Perhaps Miss CA knew that the people who support same-sex marriage are typically very abrasive, quick to anger, and intolerant of those who don’t believe like they do, so she tried in vain to calm the storm.

“After all, isn’t this title meant to demonstrate that the woman wearing the crown is the best possible representative for our nation as a whole?”

This is the funny comment I’ve been reading around the blogosphere and from Perez Hilton. The fact is, she is representing our nation as a whole. The overwhelming majority of our country does not support same-sex marriage. There are only 4 out of 50 states that currently allow same-sex marriage. California, among other states, recently reaffirmed that the majority of its citizens do not support same-sex marriage. By believing and standing by what she said, Miss CA truly does represent our nation as a whole.

I too know that the Lord Jesus Christ would not deny his love or compassion to all human beings, be they gay, straight, black, white, male or female. However, I can also testify that I know He also would not extend his approval on any same-sex relationships, or any immoral acts for that matter.

As for the ‘judge’ that asked Carrie that question, I won’t even mention his name so as not to give him another 2 seconds of fame that he does not deserve. I know nothing at all about Miss CA and the judge except what has transpired since the pageant, but from that instance alone I can now say I respect Carrie Prejean infinitely more than some no-name fashion blogger.

Well the way I see it is Ms California did exactly what she was asked to to-answer a question. Ms California is from a state that just passed a propostion to stop gay marriage. The answer she gave is the way her state majority voted, what is wrong with her advocating for them? Let’s take a closer look and see if maybe Mr Hilton didn’t have his own self interest in mind–if she answers pro gay marriage he can say “see thats what true Californians want” if she answers to the negative–well you can see what happens. I think the real issue here is the question not the answer.

Leave a Reply


  • None
  • towp: Well the way I see it is Ms California did exactly what she was asked to to-answer a question. Ms California is from a state that just passed a propos
  • Jesse: To start off, let me address your comment on "no offense." I don't know what Miss CA meant by saying that, but I can tell you that when I use that ph
  • Ian: A tip is not guaranteed. I worked 10 years in food service to help put myself through college and eventually getting my MBA. Having been on both sides

Categories